Navigating the site:

boat

Are you in my class?

Analysis

Art

Articles

Authors

Autonomy

Bibliography

Biodiversity

Briefings

Capacity

Climate

Civilization

Concepts

CORE acronym

Courses

Darwin

Demography

Design

Eco-design

Ecology

Economics

Facts

Gardens

Genes

Global Warming

Government

History

Inquiry

Knowledge

Landscape

Methods

Music

New

Office

Photographs

Plutonium

Presentations

Recent material

Research

Reviews

Science

Science subjects

Search

Site Map

Sources

Technology

Tecnology time-line

Tragedy

Utilitarian

Verbal presentations

Vita

Vocabulary

WEAL acronym

Writing

book

World view

 

Z-A site contents

 

learnlearnlearnlearnlearnlearnlearnlearnlearn

 

computer

return to top of the page


Earth

Reading

Makes No Sense

Pursell quotes Herman Melville's Captain Ahab about sane motives leading to insane ends.

Because technology is by definition a means to some defined and other, often unintended, ends.

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

Pursell's argument is developed in analogical form in Chapter 4.

He weaves social responses tightly into automotive industrial progression, worldwide warfare's demands, management of mass production, and newly emerging domestic arrangements that appear to contradict the very motives elevated by mechanization of tools.

His thesis is?

Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Hence he detects and insanity at the core of modern values; in that the head having absorbed the heart in a metaphorical sense, –because it can, because we have an appetite, and because we do not know what we have done–relentlessly subordinates all other values to an unrestrained and rigidly rational, yet still maladaptive logic that is mistaken for reason.

book Uniformity: "A new discipline had to be devised. . . Taylorism."

Standardization or tools and behavior, fifteen minute learning.

pp. 99-104.

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

line

 

Chapter 4, Mass production (1926) & Conspicuous consumption

Mass production "is the focusing upon a manufacturing project of the principles of power, accuracy, economy, system, continuity, speed and repetition."

p. 94.

"...of what is necessary for science, progress, modernism."

As a collective imperative [cultural ideology], however, the chill the heart."

p. 94.

The great schism of industrial production and personal meaning we call characteristic of the "modern mind."

p. 100-108.

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

line

Outline of Chapter Four.

  1. MacDonald's dual uniformity tied to Henry Ford's automotive revolution
  2. The assembly line innovations (an example of exaptation)
  3. The largest foundry in its time–River Rouge–employed 10,000 people
  4. Need for workers and a new factory discipline
  5. Fordism, mass production drove a movement for vertical integration
  6. The turn to Taylor whose time & motion studies suited management
  7. The "utopian dream of science based labour efficiency..." or scientific management emerged, p. 100
  8. Shop floor control of work slowly ended
  9. efficiency engineer Frank Gilbreth (1868-1924)
  10. "increasing alienation of factory labour."
  11. Unionization clashed with the mass production of Fordism and Taylorism
  12. Utopian versus distopian novels of a new industrial era
  13. "The dream of social engineering led perhaps inevitably to a turn to technocracy, the rule by a technical elite." p. 112
  14. Japanese car manufacturing superseded Fordism and Taylorism's inherent constraints
  15. Mass production's offspring are numerous from MacDonald's uniformity to high speed colliders for nuclear research to reveal quarks and bosons.

p. 117

Pursell's methodology.

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

line

An example of technology's three facets applied to automotive production.

Automobiles  
 
auto
 
three relations of tools to technology
 
Ideological responses   Social & Organizational responses
operator   Assembly plant
automated culture
 
= industrial unions for labor

line

Go here to compare the above diagram.

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

line

World War One was called the Great War, 1914-1918;

            WWI    impact & demands changed society and widespread beliefs

            1893 – seeds of the automated war were sown in two prior decades         

Boer Wars, 1880-81, & 1899-1902.    

automatic weapons & the machinery of war

scorched earth policy targeting civilians

British created concentration camps for Boers, Dutch descendants

The increasing intensity of World War I slowed the Gilbreth's work overseas.

Next

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

line

Chapter four introduces themes of insanity, speed, alienation, unification of the division of labor, and mental schizophrenia that were introduced in chapter three and will be developed coherently again in chapter five.

Structure of the book:    
 
Chapter 5-Five
 
 
 

Next.

Four: Makes no Sense

line

 Power | Standardization | Taylorism | Schism | Society | Materials | Information | Knowing | Labor

Macdonald's employees as examples of the impact of precision, uniformity, and speed on the training and behavior of unskilled and semi-skilled labor.

How the mass production in automobiles replaced hand crafted cars after 1915.

Edward Ellis M.P. and the odyssey of his 1894 purchase of an automotive vehicle in France to use in Britain.

Speed limits and distances he traveled at ten miles per hour in his new car.

Skilled craftsmen and the role of piece-by-piece hand assembly of cars.

How the Ellis experience is contrasted with Henry Ford's manufacture and his complete changes by employing (at least superficially) mass production.

94-9.

Ford 1913-1914 was a revolution in techniques that affected labor organization

98.

Frederick Winslow Taylor's Principles of Scientific Management, 1911,"his utopian dream of a science-based labour efficiency" and then when tied to Ford's adaptation of the assembly line means to a mass produced commercially viable product led to "the single largest and most integrated production plant in existence."

99.

"Ford vertically integrated his operations.…"

1913 The Highland Park plant experienced one in ten workers sick each day and example of pre-industrial expectations.

100.

To see the impacts today, see Simon Head, Mindless.

 

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

line

The Automotive revolution

Exaptation from the meat packing industry of the means by which cars -- like carcasses were brought to the worker's assembly stations from overhead (automated) delivery systems.

The River Rouge Plant

10,000 workers building cars by assembly line production

Mass production, Taylorism, scale, rigid division of labor, and the immediate result was productive outcomes in the form of more cars, made less expensively and with workers making five dollars a day in wages.

99.

line

The First World War, 1914-1918.

Belleau wood

A devastating and complete transformation of world affairs, social behavior and collapse of cultural customs that undermined European empires and hegemony.

The revolution came in social, economic, cultural, and political values.

1912, Taylor's book and the influences on management of Frank and Lillian Gilbreth's time and motion studies.

104.

Pursell detects that the hyperbole of scientifically driven progress and the promise of rational management did not correspond well with the reality in that the imagery of the happy home-maker was at odds with the grim and often mindless reality of alienation experienced by line workers at the factory in the 1917-1937 period.

1935 Lillian Gilbreth's address on the "home efficiency movement."

"Food planning in the Home to ensure satisfactory nutrition with a minimum expenditure of time, money, and labour."

105.

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

line

Technology transfer.

Ford's automobile assembly line for mass production and related labor innovations in 1914 were slowly transferable (diffusion) to Russia, Britain in 1929, and Italy in 1936 with respect to mass production.

But re-industrializing Germany in the 1933 and decade after was the best application of his means to increase production that brought down the price of cars.

107.

Consequences

J. B. Priestly observed

"men came first, machines after."

108.

The Great War, the real test of Taylorism and political upheaval–1917 the Russian Czarist Monarchy was replaced by the Mensheviks and later the Bolsheviks two factions of Communists after 1905 and 1917.

Revolution in Germany 1919, led to the creation of the Weimar Republic after then Communist uprising was defeated.

Marinnetti's futurists were an indicator of political mutation of continental European industrialization not seen in England until the 1926 General Strike of organized labor against corporate elites.

Note: The United Kingdom's General Strike lasted nine days, from 4 May to 13 May 1926.

110.

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

line

Impacts on cultural values

The declaration of the Futurists

1909 Manifesto by F. T. Marinetti

"We wish to glorify War–the only health giver of the world– militarism, patriotism, . . . the beautiful Ideas that kill…."

110.

"We shall sing of the great crowds in the excitement of labour, pleasure and rebellion…."

111.

Fritz Lang's Metropolis was a revolutionary film showing the dispensable character of the industrially skilled workers.

111.

Taylorism had the impression of political neutrality, but the power to organize work was and is a political act according to Pursell.

"The Lang film and the Krupp's filial piety echoed the already obvious Nazi commitment to efficiency and romanticism and epitomized the kernel of irrationality at the heart of Ford and Taylor's miracle."

"inevitably to a turn to technocracy"

112.

Robot was the Czech word for servile worker and was made into a cornerstone of critical literature (a play) against the role of the new machinery in turning workers into machines.

113.

The impact of industrialization on cultural motifs & social relations:

Challenge to Ford's standard model production by,

Alfred P. Sloan at GM and planned obsolescence, the yearly model change, and consumer credit (GMAC)

115.

mass markets ended up in promoting monoculture crops due to the demand for fast food and beverages.

"the offspring of mass production are numerous and varied. Agriculture reduced to monoculture, with goals of replacing natural processes and products with more readily controlled 'scientific' substitutes (chemical fertilizers for manures, genetically redesigned mammals), is one example."

The dates in Brave New World were based on BF and AF standing for Before Ford and After Ford, as a parody on Before Christ, BC, and After Christ, AD.

117.

One can discern from these examples in the chapter that the automobile and its mass production was as revolutionary as the impact of the war, on society, our behavior and imaginations.

next

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

line

Key ideas:

Division of labor is ancient and manufacture is medieval, with the coming of industrial production the necessity became:

Standardization

  • Interchangeable parts         \
                    • Case Study, automotive engineering
    • Mechanization of time         /   

Technicians’ roles peaked influencing invention with emergence of civil engineering but had its take-off in time and motion studies by Gilbreth's and Taylor.

Industrial organization of railways, automotive production, and electricity brought with it an organization of labor.

This social movement was called trade unionism of craft skilled laborers

and as opposed to:

industrial unions for semi-skilled and unskilled labor to bargain for working conditions, working hours, wages, and benefits.

 

Pursell draws a distinction between both the "human element of production," and the means of industrial routines.

p. 100.


                Technological Fixes        such as the automobile starter               

and

                Standardization which solves other sorts of technical problems
                        “Driver’s Side” culture overrides technical considerations
                               Driving on the left as opposed to right side of a road

 

Sequencing – refers to when something is invented and thereafter applied more widely

Inventions

The time between invention, testing, application and adoption often differs widely:
                       Too early
                       Too late
                                    Both are risks of standardization
                        BETA vs. VHS early action

                       Chunnel – The Channel Tunnel requires driving and drivers to shift from one side of the road to another – English (UK) Left to French (European) Right hand side of the road.
            But driving changes in France to right hand side driving as in Europe & United States.

USA
         Close up
              Scientific management

Scientific development & technological improvements are less rational than they appear to be

            Electrical – industry
                        Clearly science-based
                                    Shop floor practices helped telegraph industry:

p. 138-39.             

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

line

Details of Taylor's Scientific Management approach:

“Hand made" is replaced by automated machinery based on the social or behavioral control of work called "Taylorism" and such a shift from making things by hand and making things by machines may well have undermined innovation.

Socio-technic changes (Taylorism and Fordism) were powerful auxiliary forces that not only accompanied but may have shaped tectonic shifts to machinery with moving parts from hand tools with few or no moving parts.

Evelyn Ellis purchase of a car -- automobile in 1894 from France is a story of hand crafted imprecision and precision born of craft and hand tools.

 

The Automotive revolution will replace hand assembled cars by 1916, 1929, and 1936 worldwide.

pp. 94-92, 105-107.

Be careful of the limitations of single focus thinking.

"The shop-floor control of work."

p. 103.

Because a split is widening between practices & intentions or ideas as a response to industrial mass production, work has made workers more individually powerful in the sense of production, but less powerful in the sense of control over the production process, the affordability of the products and future decisions about productivity innovations.

 

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Pursell's summary.

Pursell's methodology.

book

runner keystone running
Step Right Up Welcome to the Club Makes No Sense
"An effort to perfect the world through rational action." "Standardization is the solution of last resort, an admission that we cannot solve the problem in any other way." Uniformity: "A new discipline had to be devised. . . Taylorism."
p. 77.
p.137. pp. 99-104.

Return to top

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Argument | Thesis | Structure | Graphic | theme | Outline | Revolution | schism | Taylorism | method

line

Citation

Reading

From Herman Melville's' novel ( fiction based on a non-fiction, or actual event ) Moby Dick,(1851);

comes the story of a whaling ship out of New Bedford bound for ignominy in the South Pacific ocean.

 

"All my means are sane, my motive and my object mad."

 

Herman Melville, Moby Dick (1964), page 318, quoted in White Heat, p.93.

Three facets' diagram | Chapter four | Outline of | Key Ideas | Theme | Events

Additional material

book
tulips
Tools of Toil: what to read.
Tools are historical building blocks of technology.

Authors:

The Two Cultures

Pursell | Pacey–World | Postman | Head | Tenner |Pacey–meaning| Eberhart | Snow | Kaku | Boulding | Delillo | Kranzberg

line

This page is was from September 29, 2007, revised September 29, 2014 .

plate